And as I was watching MSNBC this morning (where the numbers come from BTW), what killed the bill were the extreme right and left voters who didn't vote in favor of the package - they effectively canceled out the center-line moderates.
The thing is - the whole bailout package - it probably doesn't matter now anyway. Even though $700 billion is nothing to sneeze at - the markets dropped 8% yesterday to the tune of $1 trillion in losses. I don't know that even a revived bill would have any impact at this point without substantially upping the ante - to at least $1 trillion of taxpayer money. Being that the estimated budget income for 2008 is a little over $2.6 trillion, that's approaching half of what America retains in taxes.
Our economy is completely based on credit. Now stop and think about it - credit is the extension of funds based upon the credibility of future repayment. All institutions leverage credit lines based upon their certainty of future earnings and revenues (i.e. you take out a car loan at $400/mo under the reasonable assumption that you're employed and have income supposedly coming in over the term of the loan). Businesses of all sizes use credit lines (purchasing of inventory that hasn't sold yet - like stocking up for the holiday season before the items could actually be sold). Those companies that have the cash to lend to individuals or businesses make money off of their interest charged - which gets higher interest rates based upon the evaluation of the probabilty of recovery of extended funds.
Now almost everyone is familiar with how credit ratings work (to some degree or another). The higher the score, the more "credible" you are meaning by your history of management of credit you have demonstrated your ability to either repay the loan within the terms of the agreement or not. Credit can be used for direct consumption (like as a car loan) or for additional leveraging. For example, when home prices were skyrocketing, perceived equity was leveraged to allow people to borrow at lower interest rates to make a higher return (i.e. you mortgage loan was at 5% APR and you borrowed that money to make a return at 20% - netting a return of 15% on the borrowed money). It's very much like borrowing your brother's car and using it business trip where you received compensation for the use of the vehicle - you got to use other people's money to make money.
Businesses operate the same way and have credit ratings themselves. When a company is listed as "junk" it's basically stating that the probably of future earnings covering extended credit lines are near nil. It's not only turning a profit, but having sufficient cash flow internally to pay off obligations.
As entrepreneurs looked for more and more areas to make money, credit was squeezed out of every resource available. Consumer spending was maintained by individual credit card spending (and subsequent high balances) - even as wages remained flat or declined. Businesses were taking on more and more credit balances to buy inventory - big banks delved into estimated value of the housing market and sold mortgages to people who have no purpose in purchasing a home or worse yet - to those that were "buying up" to move another notch on the "keeping up with the Joneses" neighborhood swap.
Our economy - because it is based on future "tea leaf reading" of what the potential income and repayment of extended credit - is highly susceptible to irrational behaviors. Since no one can accurately predict the future, emotions come into play - and as they say, a person is smart - people are stupid. Widespread irrational exuberance or fears drive the actual outcome of the markets (the dot com and housing booms were exuberance - this "crisis" is fear). It's not that investing in businesses or banks have lost their legitimacy as money making ventures, it's just that people don't BELIEVE that they are.
So the House leaders who are trying to pass this bail out package voted ultimately against it for, what I believe, are two reasons:
- Those that voted "no" were up for reelection in tight congressional races wherein they could easily lose their seat(s).
- The collective leadership of our nation has absolutely no idea how the economy works because at the end of the day, it's based completely on collective emotional responses of (now) a worldwide scale.
We have structured our economy - from the grandest world stage to each of our own personal checkbooks - on reading the future. When the future becomes less stable (for the foreseeable time being) then people act irrationally. The bailout package is necessary only from the standpoint it shores up confidence and stubs the irrational behavior of the world economy - not necessarily to actually financially "help" these companies. The conditions attached to the bill are really political posturing - that's it.
We're all to blame so we need to stop pointing fingers. It doesn't matter nor does it affect our future. As the wonderful comedic sage Van Wilder stated: "Worrying is like a rocking chair: it gives us something to do but doesn't get us anywhere. Write that down." Pointing fingers does the very same thing.
What our country needs is something to believe in again and until that common goal is found, we're going to mire in our own self imposed depression.
Read more! Read more!

